Fb CEO Mark Zuckerberg delivers the opening keynote introducing new Fb, Messenger, WhatsApp, and Instagram privateness options on the Fb F8 Convention at McEnery Conference Heart in San Jose, California on April 30, 2019.

Amy Osborne | AFP | Getty Photos

On Tuesday, a gaggle of state attorneys common led by Texas filed a new antitrust suit towards Google. Though the swimsuit principally focuses on Google’s dominance of advert tech, it additionally accuses the corporate of conspiring with rival Facebook in a number of areas.

Amongst different allegations, the criticism claims that Google entered a take care of Fb subsidiary WhatsApp that provides Google entry to WhatsApp messaging knowledge, together with texts, pictures, and movies.

Nevertheless, Google says the declare is inaccurate, and appears to be primarily based on a misunderstanding a few backup function Google affords for WhatsApp and different messaging providers to make it simpler to switch outdated messages to a brand new cellphone.

“…shortly after Fb acquired WhatsApp, in 2015, Fb signed an unique settlement with Google, granting Google entry to thousands and thousands of Individuals’ end-to-end encrypted WhatsApp messages, pictures, movies, and audio recordsdata,” the submitting mentioned. Subsequent particulars in regards to the settlement within the swimsuit have been closely redacted.

A Google spokesperson advised CNBC that the lawsuit’s characterization is inaccurate, and the deal is a fundamental function to again up messages so that they sync from machine to machine. Google launched the backup function to assist customers switch their texts, pictures, and movies from one cellphone to a different, according to a 2015 blog post by Google. Google would not use the backup knowledge to focus on adverts, the spokesperson added.

WhatsApp started utilizing end-to-end encryption on all messages despatched by means of its service beginning in 2016. Which means messages can’t be learn by anyone however the sender and recipient. Hackers, authorized our bodies that acquire entry to the messages by means of a subpoena, and even WhatsApp itself can’t learn them.

However WhatsApp backups usually are not end-to-end encrypted, the company explains in a FAQ. As an alternative, whereas backups stay on Google Drive servers, Google has entry to the content material of that knowledge and will produce it in response to a subpoena, for instance. WhatsApp backups may be turned off.

On iPhones, WhatsApp can again messages as much as iCloud, Apple‘s cloud storage service. These backups aren’t encrypted both.

The dispute over the purpose within the lawsuit is an instance of how routine options like message backups may be forged as anticompetitive partnerships between large tech teams dealing with antitrust scrutiny. It is a minor level within the lawsuit, which focuses extra straight on alleged harms associated to how Google conducts auctions for adverts.

A WhatsApp consultant declined to remark, however Alex Stamos, a former safety govt on the firm, instructed the same interpretation.

“Fb doesn’t have that knowledge. The one rationalization may very well be the optionally available WhatsApp backup, which matches into GDrive on Android (iCloud on iOS),” Stamos tweeted.

— Jennifer Elias contributed to this story.